Past Critiques List (Organisers)

The Servant by Roger Canals

Word Count: 5000 words

Critique Date: 16 June 2026, In Person

Author Email: rc************@***il.com

Content warnings:

Abuse, Blood, Child sexual abuse, Classism, Disregard for personal autonomy (kidnapping / enslavement / abduction), Rape / Sexual Assault (or attempted), Sexism / Misogyny, Violence (gratuitous / extreme)

Author Notes:

This is the first chapter of the dark fantasy book I’m in the process of re-drafting. Being the first chapter I’m conscious of the fact that it needs to hook the reader, so I’d like to know if I’m managing to do so.

  • Is the story interesting? Does it pace well?
  • Is the theme a little too dark?
  • Are the characters believable, and do their dialogues along with their accents and dialects work?
  • Is the main character likeable?
  • Does it leave you wanting to read more?

Ultimately I’d like to know what works and what doesn’t.

Thanks!

Submitted: 4 January 2026

Last updated: 5 July 2026 at 23:05 by Jane Morecroft

Back to List